Turbulent Times for Multicultural Societies: Gap between Cultures in the Netherlands Widens Drastically by Anne Lunenburg

Thousands of Australian youths chasing and attacking fellow Australians with Middle Eastern features; French North-Africans expressing their frustrations through the use of violence in the suburbs of various French cities; Great Britain struggling against heightened racial tensions between British youth and British people of South-Asian descent. The list continues as multicultural societies face turmoil. Up next: The Netherlands?

After two years of being away from the Netherlands, I decided in November 2005 that it was time to visit family and friends in my home country. I was asked by my other friends: What do you miss the most about the Netherlands, besides your family and friends there? Without giving it much thought, I responded: Indonesian nasi goreng, Dutch meatballs, Turkish bread, and Moroccan tea with cookies. I could not help but revisit this very casual and friendly conversation that made me realize that the dishes and delicacies I miss are symbolic of the Netherlands that I know of and to which I am accustomed. Not only do my family and friends come from culturally diverse backgrounds, even my tongue is multicultural.

This is, of course, not strange considering that Lelystad, the environment that educated and nurtured me, is a multicultural city where I shared a class with children from diverse backgrounds, ranging from Moroccan, Turkish, Iranian, to Surinam, and from Indonesian to Dutch. As young students, we were brought together in celebration of the Eid Ul-Fitr (the end of the Ramadan) and Christmas, among other events, and we shared one another’s traditions and food. Growing up, I did not give this multicultural mingling at school much thought, nor did I even ponder on the fact that my mother is Dutch, my father, an Indonesian of European descent. The languages I use at home are Dutch and Indonesian, or a mixture of both. The same counts for the food on the table.

But on my return to my country that November, I was greatly disappointed to see the Netherlands plagued with religious and ethnic tension and intolerance. The gap today between the Dutch and the Dutch people with foreign backgrounds had never been wider. Anxieties over the possibility of riots and rebellion taking place in the Netherlands, similar to that of Australia and France, grow by the day. The time bomb is ticking. There is now much to fear in a country like the Netherlands.

My country has long prided itself as open and tolerant to all people, regardless of culture, creed, and sex. But leafing through the November 2005 issue of the Vrij Nederland, a Dutch opinion magazine, I stumbled upon an article that reaffirmed my strongest suspicions shortly after the outbreak of the riots in France. Indeed, we in the Netherlands are approaching potential violence. According to the article, a number of human resources personnel working in various Dutch companies revealed the unjust “unwritten policies” that appear to have been institutionalised by their respective companies in the selection of potential employees. The article said that applications submitted by people with Muslim or Muslim-sounding names were immediately rejected without even undergoing the regular and standard process of application review and evaluation.

The Netherlands is home to one million Muslims of various cultural backgrounds (the total population of the Netherlands is 16 million), who have been generalised and stigmatised by an extremely paranoid world that could not explain where and why things have gone awry, or possibly, refuses to acknowledge the root causes of violence, inequalities, and inequities. Dutch Muslims, similar to the general Muslim population worldwide, suffer religious and hate propaganda that had gained much fervor since the terrorist attacks of 9/11. Europe, home to a huge Muslim population, is approaching trying times. The Netherlands is not excluded.

At the home front, while our Dutch Muslims struggle against the social stigma that has intensified over the years, the recent brutal murder of Theo van Gogh, a Dutch moviemaker and producer who released a movie that critiqued Islam, did nothing but escalate and validates the perceptions of the anti-Islam population of the Netherlands.

According to Anja, Muslim women do find spaces to combine feminism with the teachings of Islam. But, unfortunately, the voices of these progressive women are silenced by more influential people such as parliamentarians and the mainstream media.

Instead of building bridges and addressing inequalities and inequities at all levels, parliamentarians and politicians like Ayaan Hirsi Ali have done nothing but widen the gap between Muslims and non-Muslims.

Many multicultural societies believe that they are models of tolerance and social equality. But are they truly what they claim themselves to be? As an optimist privileged to have grown up in and benefited from an environment that is culturally diverse, I would like to say yes. However, as events unfold before my eyes, I see more and more multicultural societies taking a perilous path to chaos.

The disenfranchised, the oppressed, and the marginalised will stand up united and strong, and all forms of state violence will be met with equal wrath and hatred. This spiral of violence will continue unless civil society and the social movements come together to simultaneously counter our states as well as attempt to temper the brewing resentments and vindications of the oppressed.

Anne Lunenburg is a Dutch freelance journalist who has a passion for multiculturalism. He recently interned at the Asian Migrant Centre in Hong Kong.

Share this post

Submit to FacebookSubmit to Google PlusSubmit to Twitter

facebook rndyoutube rnd twitter rnd